The votes tallied with an astoundingly close race. Gilmer County has elected as their new Probate Judge.
Some precincts came in as low as only 5-7% of registered voters turning out to their precinct Tuesday. At the end of the night, the votes set Scott Chastain at a grand total of 1,122 and Josh Teague at 1,090.
The sentiment was echoed by Chairman of the Gilmer County Republican Party Stephen Aaron, “I said it very early on that it’s rare to have so many good people running for an office, and it’s great that the voters of Gilmer County spoke.”
Though both candidates showed great emotion as the results came in, it only served to mask the stress of an election that sat at a 3 vote difference when the precincts were counted, it came out that the early voting and absentee ballots set the final 32 vote difference that set Scott Chastain on top of the election.
The final tally of the precincts totaled:
Big Creek
Scott Chastain – 55
Josh Teague – 47
Boardtown
Scott Chastain – 49
Josh Teague – 39
Cartecay
Scott Chastain – 90
Josh Teague – 66
Cherry Log
Scott Chastain – 38
Josh Teague – 18
East Ellijay
Scott Chastain – 71
Josh Teague – 67
Ellijay NE
Scott Chastain – 45
Josh Teague – 41
Ellijay N
Scott Chastain – 58
Josh Teague – 63
Ellijay S
Scott Chastain – 60
Josh Teague – 69
Leaches
Scott Chastain – 39
Josh Teague – 51
Mountain Town
Scott Chastain – 38
Josh Teague – 45
Tails Creek
Scott Chastain – 33
Josh Teague – 47
Town Creek
Scott Chastain – 28
Josh Teague – 41
Yukon
Scott Chastain – 49
Josh Teague – 56
Mail-ins
Scott Chastain – 60
Josh Teague – 66
Early Voting
Scott Chastain – 409
Josh Teague – 374
Meet Tippy Dot, a sweet, playful girl who always wants to please the person she…
Arrest report provided by the Gilmer County Sheriff’s Office requested by us. The Georgia Open…
GILMER COUNTY, Ga. - The National Weather Service office in Peachtree City, Georgia has issued…
Come make an arrangement for your Easter table at our first bouquet bar of 2026!…
Meet Sorrel, a 2-years young, 58 pounds of lab-mix blended mix of charm and sweetness,…
GEORGIA - Conservative Senator Steve Gooch is stepping up where others are content to grandstand,…